Will sin bins tackle dissent in grassroots football?

Read More

How to bowl fast in cricket

There’s nothing more thrilling in cricket to watch than an exceptional fast bowler, gliding in and hurling down thunderbolts at batsmen from 22 yards.
Continue Reading
February 17, 2020
Back to Blog home

Will sin bins tackle dissent in grassroots football?

Football law changes - referee surroundingWe are into the 2019/20 football season and one of the most significant changes for grassroots football has come into effect.

Sin bins, or temporary dismissals, are being more widely introduced across grassroots football (including youth, veterans, and disability) in an effort to tackle bad behaviour.

This specific move against players dissent (by word or action) has been targeted by the Football Association (FA) to improve the match day experience and in support of their RESPECT programme.

blog-sin-bins-in-football-referee-yellow-cardIt now means referees can issue a yellow card, point to the sidelines and an adult footballer has to sit out a 10-minute period from the game. It is an 8-minute sin bin for a junior.

Examples of dissent (see FA download) might be:

• Shouting at the ref
• Questioning ref’s ability
• Slamming the ball in to the ground
• Sarcastically clapping a decision

This rugby-style punishment is geared towards improving the retention of referees and enhancing the image of the game.

It ought to be noted this isn’t something entirely new. 31 leagues have used the system over the past two seasons, with the trials showing that it led to a 38% reduction in dissent.

It’s a common-sense policy aimed at stamping out a problem that blights grassroots football - but it does raise the odd question.

There is scope for interpretation as to what constitutes dissent - but it's up to officials to enforce it strictly.


It does give a referee something else to think about (tracking when sin bins start and end) but has got to be better than being subjected to verbal abuse for 90 minutes.

It will take time to bed in and lessons will be learnt but the County FAs are offering training to referees and players will think twice before risking a spell on the sidelines.

It’s a significant sanction that can have a noticeable effect on the outcome of a match. In rugby union, the average number of points conceded when a player is sin-binned can be 7 or more (a converted try). 

Football law changes - ref pic-1We should safeguard our officials, make football less confrontational and also set a better example to those spectating.

There’s no question the threat of punishing a team with the temporary loss of a player will cause many to keep their thoughts to themselves.

Time will tell how much impact the threat of a sin bin has on reducing dissent in football but the early signs are promising.

Related Posts

Final Whistle app targets hate crime

Final Whistle™ is an app designed for clubs, created by David Frazier and Ricky Kundi in association with...
Continue Reading

The Club Guide to Emoji Meanings

Welcome to the weird and wonderful world of emoji meanings. How sports clubs communicate on social media ...
Continue Reading

Can you help Luke Mortimer?

Seven-year-old Luke Mortimer needs our help. Before Christmas, the young rugby player from Skipton RUFC c...
Continue Reading